Homegrounds is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.Learn more.

Percolator vs Drip咖啡机:有什么区别?

It’s the battle of the old-school coffee makers. These two machines have been around for decades and have been thoroughly tried and tested. We explore where these two shine and where they fall short.

当涉及渗滤剂与滴水咖啡时,哪一种适合您?阅读我们的指南以找出答案。

咖啡渗透剂

coffee percolator今天似乎有些老式,但是它的发明是迈向酿造更好咖啡的重要一步。在此之前,人们只是通过沸腾的水块来煮咖啡 - 一种称为咖啡酿造方法decoction((1)。

人们创建了渗滤剂来生产一杯清洁的咖啡,没有地面。这与法国新闻咖啡有些相似。

有关的:French Press vs Coffee Percolator

渗滤剂通过加热水来工作,直到有足够的压力将其通过管向上推动。然后,它掉进了咖啡景,然后返回水库。水继续本周期,直到从热量中取出,从而形成了机器签名的更强壮的咖啡。这确实使Percolator Coffe Coffe的说唱有些不好,但粉丝们说这是您如何如何看待您的问题use它:

Percolator在生产苦咖啡方面的声誉可能更多地与渗透咖啡的人持续太久有关。

Here’s amore detailed article关于它的工作方式。有了正确的技术和对细节的关注,您应该能够获得强大但不过高的咖啡。

Drip Coffee Makers

这arrival of thedrip coffee makerwas a death knell for the humble percolator. The design completely automated the process, reducing user error, and allowing people to do other things while their coffee brewed.

滴水咖啡机以与倒入相同的理论作用,但是所产生的咖啡有很大的不同。水在机器中加热,慢慢滴入地面咖啡,产生光滑但温和的冲泡。

I love being able to really taste the beans in drip coffee – espresso is amazing but I like spreading out the experience.

滴水咖啡可能没有其他酿造方法的冲击,但它确实可以让您品尝咖啡的微妙之处。请注意,变暖板是滴水机的重要优势之一,可能会损害味道(2)。

If you want to see how drip coffee stacks up与法国出版社相比,我们也有指南。

For a guide on brewing perfect drip coffee at home, watch our video:

Comparing the details: Percolator vs Drip Coffee Maker

现在您对这些机器有所了解,Percolator Coffee与Drip如何比较?该方法是一回事,但最终,它归结为在您的需求和口味方面最适合您。

咖啡渗透剂与滴水比较

Ease of use/skill required

You really can’t go too far wrong with classic drip coffee makers. The process is automated from start to finish. Unless you forget to add the coffee grounds or fill up the water tank, you’ll have a great cup of coffee every time without any issues.

可编程的滴水咖啡机可以使您调整强度或保持温度的温度,但是将其剩下的咖啡机一旦设置了。

Stovetop Percolators需要使用一些练习。另外,如果您想完善咖啡,则可能需要尝试变量。您也有可能使其无人看管并完全燃烧您的啤酒。尽管如此,现代渗滤剂仍将消除人类错误的一些元素。酿造温度受到调节,大多数人在完成酿造过程时会切换到保存模式。

WINNER:这drip machine comes out on top for this one. Getting your hands on a fresh cup of coffee is really just a matter of adding the grounds and flicking a switch.

Versatility

这flipside to any automation when it comes to coffee machines is the lack of control you have. A drip coffee maker is undoubtedly convenient but not necessarily the best choice if you want to tweak your coffee to your exact requirements. Some high-end drip machines allow you to program elements such as brew strength or keep-warm temperature, but ultimately, this is an automatic process.

有了炉灶渗透剂,咖啡的命运就掌握在您的手中。

You will need to reach a specific water temperature to start the percolation; how quickly you get there, but how long you keep it boiling and how long it stays in the heat is up to you. The percolator itself is also variable. Along with the choice of electric or stovetop, you’ll also get the option of materials like stainless steel, ceramic, and glass.

WINNER:Percolator的手册使用在调整啤酒方面有所回报。另外,这是您可以在露营旅行中进行的唯一一个。

容量

这两台机器均设计为一次酿造多杯咖啡。与浓缩咖啡机或Aeropress不同,Percolator和Drip Machine更适合家庭友好。滴水咖啡机最多将酿造14杯,而且很容易看出为什么它们是一个如此受欢迎的办公室咖啡机。

家居渗滤剂的尺寸与滴水咖啡机的尺寸大致相同,通常最大容量为12杯。但是,如果您在餐饮活动中曾经喝过咖啡,那就是您要喝的大型渗滤剂。

WINNER:如果您正在寻找家用机器,那么这两个咖啡机的容量都相当。但是,如果您是人群,只有咖啡渗透器提供20杯容量机。

Taste

这两台机器之间的口味差异是由于咖啡和水的整合方式。借助滴水咖啡机,这本质上是一种自动倾倒技术。热水仅通过地面就经过一次,形成了温和,光滑的酿造咖啡。为了获得最佳风味,请不要将咖啡壶放在变暖板上。

Those who swear by their percolator love the fact that the coffee is so bold. The continually circulating water is passed multiple times through the grounds to create this full-bodied brew. This is also the method’s downfall, as keeping it moving requires boiling water (or close to it), which can over-extract or burn the coffee (3)。

WINNER:虽然确实归结为个人喜好,但最终,我们将不得不与Drip Codeaker一起使用。它没有折磨咖啡的力量,但确实会更加尊重豆类。

这verdict

这可能不是您要寻找的答案,但事实是,在咖啡方面,这完全取决于什么like to drink. Each machine has its pros and cons, its fans, and its critics.

如果你想要一个完全fuss-free体验每个morning (and let’s face it, who doesn’t?), you can’t go past the automatic drip machines. It’s a foolproof method of brewing consistent coffee that requires nothing more than filling it up and switching it on. It’ll even keep your coffee warm if you’re planning a second cup.

For those who like their first cup of joe to be hot and strong, percolator coffee will give you that kickstart to the day. If you select a stovetop version, you’ll also have the ability to tweak your brew time to achieve the perfect strength.

常见问题解答

Drip coffee is not the same as pour over. However, it can be seen as a fully automated pour over because it has the same primary method. Still, with pour-over coffee, the ability to adjust brew time, water flow, and temperature affect both the final brew’s flavor and texture.

Percolator咖啡对你并不坏。然而,斯图dies have shown that any unfiltered coffee, such as that made with a percolator, contains higher levels of oils known as cafestol and kahweol. These are known to raise cholesterol levels and have been linked to cardiovascular disease. However, just as important is whether you add cream or sugar to your coffee (4)。

Don’t use drip grind coffee in a percolator. A drip machine can take a finer grind due to the paper filter. The percolator’s metal filter will allow this fine grind to pass through and you will end up with grounds in the coffee.

  1. Meister. (2018, August 09). Coffee History: The Percolator. Retrieved from https://www.seriouseats.com/coffee-history-the-percolator-how-it-works-history
  2. Christof,T。(2015年1月13日)。如何制作一杯非常好的滴水咖啡。取自https://www.foodandwine.com/drinks/how-make-really-good-cup-drip-coffee
  3. Cadwalader, Z. (2017, March 29). Kickstarter: Perk Brings The Percolator To The Modern Age. Retrieved from https://sprudge.com/kickstarter-perk-brings-percolator-modern-age-117964.html
  4. Yu, Y. (2020, April 29). What is the healthiest way to brew coffee? Retrieved from https://www.today.com/health/what-healthiest-way-brew-coffee-t180152

克什米尔·布鲁梅尔(Kashmir Brummel)
Growing up in a coffee-free household, the discovery of the Moka pot as a teen was something of a revelation. I’ve now upgraded to the AeroPress for my daily brew, with a Hario V60 on hand for lazy weekend mornings.

[class^=“ wpforms-”]
[class^=“ wpforms-”]
[50% OFF]
[50% OFF]
[class^=“ wpforms-”]
[class^=“ wpforms-”]
[50% OFF]
[50% OFF]
[class^=“ wpforms-”]
[class^=“ wpforms-”]
[50% OFF]
[50% OFF]